Can someone please explain this idea of cultural appropriation to me? I understand that pretending to be something you are not is never a good idea. By the way, that goes for a multitude of topics including being a good cook, dancer or tax accountant. But when did it become inappropriate to celebrate the intrinsic beauty of other religions, cultures, ethnicities or organizations? And let’s think about this, how far can this really go? In today’s climate is it so far fetched to say that all those drunken morons, when “Everyone is Irish on St. Patrick’s Day” put on their counterfeit Aran sweaters and pretend to know how to ceili are guilty of cultural appropriation? Should we quit dying the river green and limit parade marchers to those that can pass an Ancestry.com DNA test? If the answer is yes, the whiskey industry in this country is in a heap of trouble.
The fabrics used to make the Indian Sari can be some of the most stunningly beautiful I have ever seen. Does that mean that I can not dress in a Sari if done so in a respectful manner? What about the beauty of the Ankara textile? Do you have to be Jamaican to wear dreads? – if yes there are a lot of inappropriate hipsters out there that need a haircut. Have we eliminated an entire segment of embarrassing childhood photos by not letting suburban kids from Nebraska get cornrows braided into their hair on their Car-a-BEE-inn vacation? Can you only wear Birkenstocks with socks if you are of German heritage? Don’t get me started on Lederhosen! Where does it end I ask you!?
My grandmother wore a mezuzah on a chain next to a medal of the Pope. She wasn’t Jewish and some would argue she wasn’t really Catholic either but they were part of her life story. She wasn’t being disrespectful to anyone or any belief. If anything, she was honoring both sides of her Judeo-Christian heritage. Not everything has to be about wanting to appropriate something for yourself – maybe its just about celebrating the beauty, history and culture of those NOT yourself. Now, where is my Aran sweater?
